Anti-Drone System Compliance Comparison - FTA1

Anti-Drone System Compliance Comparison

Customer Requirements vs FTA1 TDOA+AOA Drone Detector

#Customer RequirementFTA1 OfferStatusRemarks
1DetectionProvidedMATCHDetection capability is provided.
2AlertingSound or light alarmMATCHAlerting requirement is covered.
3No jamming (legal)Passive; no signal emissionMATCHCritical legal requirement is met.
4RF passive detectionPassive detection with spectrum scanningMATCHCompliant.
5Frequencies: 900 MHz, 2.4 GHz, 5.8 GHz100 MHz–6 GHz scanning / 2 GHz–6 GHz direction findingPARTIALThe requested bands are not explicitly listed exactly as requested.
6Detect droneProvidedMATCHCompliant.
7Detect operatorNot clearly confirmedNOT MATCHOperator detection is not explicitly stated as a requirement-matching function.
8Screenshot imageNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo screenshot function is stated.
9Friendly / enemy drone listNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo blacklist/whitelist function is explicitly stated.
10Remote managementAPI, electronic maps, networking, recordsPARTIALSoftware/networking functions exist, but remote management is not explicitly stated in the same way.
11Type: PassivePassiveMATCHCompliant.
12Range: up to 5 km2–5 kmMATCHCompliant.
13Frequencies: 25 MHz – 6 GHz100 MHz – 6 GHzPARTIAL25–100 MHz lower range is missing.
14Detection: >90% (commercial & FPV)Not specifiedNOT MATCHNo explicit detection-rate confirmation.
15Drone & operator locationDrone direction finding and network location; operator location not explicitly confirmedPARTIALDrone location exists; operator location is not clearly confirmed.
16Audio alertSound or light alarmMATCHAudio alert is included.
17App supportNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo app support confirmation.
18Detection Range: 0–5 km2–5 kmPARTIALUpper end matches; lower end is not stated as 0 km.
19Sensitivity: ≥ -95 dBmNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo sensitivity figure is stated.
20Accuracy: up to 3°Approx. 10° directional accuracyNOT MATCHWorse than requested.
21Direction: 360°360° passive detectionMATCHCompliant.
22Drones simultaneously: ≥35≥20 simultaneous targetsNOT MATCHShortfall versus requirement.
23Temperature: -40 to +70°C-40 to +65°CPARTIALUpper operating temperature is lower.
24Operation: 24/724/7 operationMATCHCompliant.
25Power: 110–240VAC 220V / DC 12VPARTIALNot identical to requested 110–240V range.
26Dimensions: 410×330×190 mm420×530 mmNOT MATCHDifferent dimensions/form factor.
27Weight: 12.8 kgApprox. 15 kgPARTIALHeavier than requested.
28Commercial offer includes: Drone DetectorDevice host includedMATCHDetector device is included.
29Commercial offer includes: Control laptopNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo control laptop is stated.
30Commercial offer includes: Remote management systemAPI/networking/maps availablePARTIALFunctionality exists, but not clearly stated as included commercial item.
31Commercial offer includes: InstallationEasy installation stated, but service not explicitly includedPARTIALInstallation service not clearly confirmed.
32Commercial offer includes: TrainingNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo training is stated.
33Commercial offer includes: MaintenanceNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo maintenance is stated.
34Terms: Warranty covers transport & reinstallationNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo such warranty term is stated.
35Terms: ManualsNot specifiedNOT MATCHManuals are not explicitly stated.

Fully Compliant

12

Partially Compliant

9

Not Compliant

14

Final Conclusion

The FTA1 offer meets the customer’s key requirement for passive non-jamming anti-drone detection and also covers several core points such as detection, alerting, 360° coverage, and 24/7 operation.

However, compared strictly against the customer requirement list, it remains significantly less compliant than FD1, especially in operator detection, friendly/enemy list, accuracy, detection-rate confirmation, and several commercial inclusions and terms.