Anti-Drone System Compliance Comparison - HS-307

Anti-Drone System Compliance Comparison

Customer Requirements vs HS-307 Drone Detection & Jamming Integrated

#Customer RequirementHS-307 OfferStatusRemarks
1DetectionProvidedMATCHDetection capability is provided.
2AlertingSystem alerting/interface functions are shownPARTIALAlerting is present, but not stated exactly as customer wording except through system functions.
3No jamming (legal)Integrated jamming / countermeasure unit includedNOT MATCHCritical legal/customer requirement is violated.
4RF passive detectionPassive detection positioningMATCHDetection unit is passive.
5Frequencies: 900 MHz, 2.4 GHz, 5.8 GHz900 MHz, 1.5 GHz, 2.4 GHz, 5.8 GHzMATCHAll requested core bands are included.
6Detect droneProvidedMATCHCompliant.
7Detect operatorPilot positioning providedMATCHCompliant.
8Screenshot imageNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo screenshot function is stated.
9Friendly / enemy drone listBlack and white listMATCHEquivalent functionality is provided.
10Remote managementMap system, controls, device list, detection list, offline map downloadPARTIALAdvanced software functions exist, but remote management is not explicitly stated as in customer wording.
11Type: PassiveDetection unit passive, overall system integrated with jammingPARTIALDetection part is passive, but full system is not passive-only due to integrated countermeasure unit.
12Range: up to 5 km1–5 km detection radiusMATCHCompliant.
13Frequencies: 25 MHz – 6 GHz100 MHz – 6 GHzPARTIAL25–100 MHz lower range is missing.
14Detection: >90% (commercial & FPV)Not specifiedNOT MATCHNo explicit detection-rate confirmation.
15Drone & operator locationReal-time drone and pilot positioningMATCHCompliant.
16Audio alertNot explicitly stated in technical parameter tablePARTIALAlarm functions exist, but audio alert is not clearly confirmed in the offer text.
17App supportNot specified as app-basedNOT MATCHNo app support confirmation.
18Detection Range: 0–5 km1–5 kmPARTIALUpper end matches; lower end is not stated as 0 km.
19Sensitivity: ≥ -95 dBmNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo sensitivity figure is stated.
20Accuracy: up to 3°Positioning accuracy ≤10 mPARTIALPosition accuracy is stated, but angular accuracy in degrees is not directly confirmed.
21Direction: 360°Not explicitly statedNOT MATCH360° coverage is not clearly confirmed in the offer text.
22Drones simultaneously: ≥35≥10 simultaneous targetsNOT MATCHSignificant shortfall versus requirement.
23Temperature: -40 to +70°CNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo operating temperature range is stated in the offer text provided here.
24Operation: 24/7Ability to continuously detect, locate and counter drones while movingPARTIALContinuous operation is implied, but 24/7 is not clearly specified.
25Power: 110–240VNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo power supply range is stated.
26Dimensions: 410×330×190 mm600×420 mm (cylindrical format)NOT MATCHDifferent dimensions/form factor.
27Weight: 12.8 kg≤30 kg (excluding power)NOT MATCHSubstantially heavier than requested.
28Commercial offer includes: Drone DetectorDetector device includedMATCHDetector device is included.
29Commercial offer includes: Control laptopNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo control laptop is stated.
30Commercial offer includes: Remote management systemSystem interface and map controls exist, but not explicitly stated as included itemPARTIALFunctionality exists, but inclusion as commercial deliverable is not clearly confirmed.
31Commercial offer includes: InstallationCan be installed fixed or on vehicle, but service not explicitly includedPARTIALInstallability is described, not installation service.
32Commercial offer includes: TrainingNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo training is stated.
33Commercial offer includes: MaintenanceNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo maintenance is stated.
34Terms: Warranty covers transport & reinstallationNot specifiedNOT MATCHNo such warranty term is stated.
35Terms: ManualsNot specifiedNOT MATCHManuals are not explicitly stated.

Fully Compliant

10

Partially Compliant

10

Not Compliant

15

Final Conclusion

The HS-307 offer covers several functional points such as drone detection, pilot positioning, black/white list functionality, and the required core drone frequency bands.

However, when measured strictly against the customer requirements, it is not suitable as a compliant solution mainly because it includes integrated jamming/countermeasure capability, which directly conflicts with the customer’s no jamming (legal) requirement.

It also falls short in several technical and commercial requirements, including simultaneous target capacity, screenshot support, app support, dimensions/weight, and multiple required commercial inclusions and terms.